Blog

What students say must be true

There were several places where one of us said things that weren’t true:

  • at one point Anthea said « Són dos quarts de sis del matí » and then « Són dos quarts de sis de la tarda » … and I said ‘Both of those cannot be true’. The point being that if we allow students to say things like this then they might be just doing an intellectual exercise in manipulating words. This is absolutely not what we want: we want them tying together the words appropriate to the situation they are talking about. So ‘everything must be true’!
  • A bit later I said « Un quart de quatre del matí » and Anthea said ‘No!’ « Un quart de cinc » … She was right, of course.

    This is also important. We don’t know from what I had said if a) I’d muddled up « quatre » and « cinc » or b) I’d forgotten the key part of this structure: that we are talking about a quarter to the next hour or c) I was so focused on bits of the language that I hadn’t properly looked at the clock or d) I’d just made a slip.

    The only way to find out which of these four possibilities it is is for someone to say ‘Problem!’ or ‘No!’ or something and get me to try again. And what I had said needed to be corrected not only for my sake, but for everyone else in the class. So ‘everything must be true’!
  • A bit later in answer to the question « Qui té dues regletes? » I answered « La Maria les té » which everyone saw was incorrect. Everyone also reacted in exactly the right way – my assumption was that it was my language that was wrong, and you all let me flounder around for a bit until someone pointed to Anthea’s box and I realised what was going on! This, of course, then opened up some interesting language! So ‘everything must be true’!

This is an important principle of the Silent Way approach right from the start, through to the most advanced level: ‘everything must be true’. Since we aren’t just manipulating words and we aren’t translating, this whole approach depends on forging a precise relationship between things as they really are and the language.

We aren’t at this stage yet, but later on when students start to talk about their own lives we want them talking about what actually happened, not some fiction or role play. And when we get to more abstract conversations, where things aren’t as visible as they are at this stage, we want students to add words like ‘I think’ or ‘I hope’ or ‘I believe’ etc because these turn speculative statements into true ones.

Who am I talking to?

In a similar vein:

At 54 minutes we ended up with the sentence « La Maria i l’Anthea tenen dues regletes ». In fact, at the moment that I said this sentence, I thought I was talking to Anthea. So, what I said was grammatically incorrect, and should not have been accepted. This underlines the importance of insisting students are clear who they are talking to: only then do we know if their sentence is correct or not.

In fact, I realised just afterwards that it was only correct if I was talking to Marta or Assum. But most students won’t realise this kind of thing, so you, as teachers, need to insist on clarity and you need to get everything corrected.